From the Westminster College Parent Blog · Author: Lana Whitehead, Vice President for Enrollment Management Reading time: about 6 minutes 

Before there's an application, there's a bigger question: where? And if the application season has a clear rulebook — deadlines, forms, a submit button — the search season is foggier. There are roughly 4,000 colleges in America. Your student has to get from 4,000 to one. 

That's not a solo project, and it shouldn't be. The search is actually where a parent's involvement helps most — as long as it takes the right shape. Same principle as the application itself: be the guide, not the driver. Here's how. 

First, expand the search — then narrow it

It sounds backwards, but the best college lists start by getting bigger. Most students begin with the handful of schools they've heard of: where friends are going, the local names, the teams on TV. Familiarity isn't fit. Some of the best-fit colleges in the country — including, we'd humbly submit, a certain one in New Wilmington, PA — aren't household names, because they spend their money on professors and scholarships instead of billboards and commercials. 

So early on — sophomore and junior year is perfect — encourage your student to look past the schools they can already name. Then narrow with purpose. A healthy final list is a manageable handful of schools your student would genuinely be happy to attend — not twenty applications fired in every direction. 

Help them figure out what they actually want — by asking, not answering 

Early in the search, most students can't tell you what they want in a college because they've never had to think about it. This is a place where a parent is genuinely useful — not by handing them a list of schools, but by asking the questions that help them discover their own preferences. Try these on a car ride: 

• Do you want professors who know your name, or would you rather blend into a big crowd? 
• Can you picture yourself in a city, or somewhere quieter? 
• Close enough to come home for a weekend, or far enough to feel brand new? 
• What's something you'd be sad to give up — playing your sport, performing, a job, Sunday dinners? 

There are no wrong answers — but their answers will shrink a list of thousands of colleges down to a manageable handful fast. 

Two cautions from the admissions side of the desk. First, notice whose preferences are filling the list. It's natural to nudge toward the school you love, the one close to home, or the name that impresses the neighbors — but a student who chooses a college to please someone else often struggles to stay at it. Second, don't let sticker price cut a school before you've seen the real numbers. "Fit" includes affordability, absolutely — but as we tell families all the time, what a college publishes and what your family pays are two very different figures. Keep the maybe-list generous until the actual offers arrive.

Do the homework you can do from the couch 

Before anyone gets in a car, the internet does a lot of narrowing for free: 

• Take the virtual tour. Most colleges (including Westminster) offer one. A twenty-minute virtual visit will tell your student whether a campus is worth a real one. 
• Check the majors — actually check. Don't assume every college teaches everything. Pull up the academic programs page and make sure your student's interests are there — and if they're undecided, look for schools where exploring is built in rather than penalized. 
• Read like a detective. Class sizes, what graduates go on to do, what students say about their professors. The clues to fit are published on college websites; most families just never look. 
• Dig deeper than the AI overview. The AI summary at the top of your search can be outdated or simply wrong about deadlines, scholarships, and costs — always verify the numbers on the college's own website. And even when it's accurate, an AI overview can only tell you what a college is, never what it feels like. That part still requires humans: a visit, a conversation, a professor, a sidewalk.  

Speaking of sidewalks - nothing replaces standing on the campus. A student can love a school on paper and feel nothing on the sidewalk. Or they could walk onto a campus they'd barely considered and quietly say, "I could live here." Trust that feeling. It's data. 

And one visit isn't really enough for a front-runner. A campus feels different on a quiet summer afternoon than on a Tuesday when classes are changing. Come for a daily tour first; come back for an event day when campus is in full swing. (At Westminster, that's Fall Open House, Discovery Day — where your student sits in on real classes — and Accepted Student Day. And our Visit Grant takes $1,000 off the first year just for coming to see us.) 

On the visit itself, one tip: help your student prepare two or three questions they'll ask, and let yours be the second voice, not the first. What they choose to ask — and how they light up (or don't) at the answers — will tell you more about fit than any brochure. 

Talk to the people, not just the tour guide 

The single most underused move in the college search: ask to talk to a professor. If your student has an academic interest, admissions can usually arrange a conversation with faculty in that department — and fifteen minutes with a professor reveals more about what four years will feel like than any webpage. Current students are gold too: ask the tour guide what they'd change about their school and watch whether the answer is honest. At a college where students are known, they'll talk about their professors by name. Listen for that. 

The quick reference version 

Yours: the wide net, the car-ride questions, the transportation, the honest budget conversation, the patience. 

Theirs: the preferences, the questions on tours, the gut feeling on the sidewalk, the final list. 

Ours: the access. Campus visits, conversations with faculty and coaches, honest answers about fit — that's what we're here for. Find your admissions counselor [link] or call the Office of Admissions at (724) 946-7100. One phone call (or quick email) usually saves a week of wondering. 

The search ends the way it should when the student who presses "submit" is applying to schools they chose, for reasons they can name. Get them there, and the application season — that's the next post — takes care of itself. 

Lana Whitehead is Westminster College's Vice President for Enrollment Management, leading the Offices of Admissions and Financial Aid. She's spent her career helping students get into college, get through college, get launched, and keep learning — and as a mom of six adult children, she's done the same at her own kitchen table, six times over. 

More Stories