| 4th Quarter Play-by-Play |
| Thi | 2-8 | on Wes14 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Thi | 2-8 | on Wes14 | Andrew Smith rush for no gain to the WES14 (Chuck Sayre;Nate Moot). |
| Thi | 3-8 | on Wes14 | Andrew Smith pass intercepted by Nate Moot at the WES15, Nate Moot return 21 yards to the WES36 (Andrew Smith). |
| | Drive: 9 plays, 37 yards, TOP 4:38 |
| Wes | 1-10 | on Wes36 | WESTMINSTER drive start at 14:13. |
| Wes | 1-10 | on Wes36 | Tyler Banks rush for loss of 5 yards to the WES31 (Ethan Ludwig). |
| Wes | 2-15 | on Wes31 | Tyler Banks rush for 6 yards to the WES37 (Kris Tursky;M. Hainesworth). |
| Wes | 3-9 | on Wes37 | Dak Britt pass incomplete to Tyler Banks (Tim Taylor). |
| Wes | 4-9 | on Wes37 | J. Schnelbach punt 32 yards to the THI31, fair catch by Bill Frizzi. |
| | Drive: 3 plays, 1 yard, TOP 1:46 |
| Thi | 1-10 | on Thi31 | THIEL drive start at 12:27. |
| Thi | 1-10 | on Thi31 | Taylor Fink rush for 2 yards to the THI33 (Taylor Heinrich). |
| Thi | 2-8 | on Thi33 | Andrew Smith pass incomplete (Taylor Heinrich). |
| Thi | 3-8 | on Thi33 | Andrew Smith pass complete to Taylor Fink for 10 yards to the THI43, 1ST DOWN THI (Alex Kernicky;Justin Shaw). |
| Thi | 1-10 | on Thi43 | Andrew Smith pass complete to Matt Fedzen for 16 yards to the WES41, 1ST DOWN THI (Josh Beistel). |
| Thi | 1-10 | on Wes41 | Taylor Fink rush for 4 yards to the WES37 (Alex Kernicky). |
| Thi | 2-6 | on Wes37 | Taylor Fink rush for 5 yards to the WES32 (J.J. Nalesnik). |
| Thi | 3-1 | on Wes32 | Andrew Smith rush for 2 yards to the WES30, 1ST DOWN THI (Christofferson;Chuck Sayre). |
| Thi | 1-10 | on Wes30 | Taylor Fink rush for 2 yards to the WES28 (D. Donikowski;Christofferson). |
| Thi | 2-8 | on Wes28 | Andrew Smith sacked for loss of 7 yards to the WES35 (Chuck Sayre). |
| Thi | 3-15 | on Wes35 | Andrew Smith pass complete to Berend Grube for 8 yards to the WES27 (Taylor Heinrich;Josh Beistel). |
| Thi | 4-7 | on Wes27 | Andrew Smith rush for 10 yards to the WES17, 1ST DOWN THI (Taylor Heinrich;Rocky Radeff). |
| Thi | 1-10 | on Wes17 | Taylor Fink rush for loss of 2 yards to the WES19 (Nate Moot). |
| Thi | 2-12 | on Wes19 | Taylor Fink rush for 8 yards to the WES11 (Josh Beistel). |
| Thi | 3-4 | on Wes11 | Andrew Smith rush for 11 yards to the WES0, 1ST DOWN THI, TOUCHDOWN, clock 04:52. |
| | | Jon Fennick kick attempt failed. |
| Thiel 16, Westminster 7 |
| | Drive: 14 plays, 69 yards, TOP 7:35 |
| | | Berend Grube kickoff 65 yards to the WES0, touchback. |
| Wes | 1-10 | on Wes25 | WESTMINSTER drive start at 04:52. |
| Wes | 1-10 | on Wes25 | Dak Britt pass complete to G. Pasquinelli for 35 yards to the THI40, 1ST DOWN WES (Walt Litwin). |
| Wes | 1-10 | on Thi40 | Dak Britt sacked for loss of 4 yards to the THI44 (Reily Shane). |
| Wes | 2-14 | on Thi44 | Dak Britt pass complete to G. Pasquinelli for 10 yards to the THI34 (Rob Edwards), PENALTY THI roughing passer (Jack Sindlinger) 15 yards to the THI19, 1ST DOWN WES. |
| Wes | 1-10 | on Thi19 | 1st and 10. |
| Wes | 1-10 | on Thi19 | Dak Britt pass incomplete to G. Pasquinelli, QB hurry by Reily Shane. |
| Wes | 2-10 | on Thi19 | Dak Britt sacked for loss of 10 yards to the THI29 (Reily Shane). |
| Wes | 3-20 | on Thi29 | Timeout Westminster, clock 03:16. |
| Wes | 3-20 | on Thi29 | Dak Britt pass complete to Collin Wallace for 14 yards to the THI15. |
| Wes | 4-6 | on Thi15 | Timeout Thiel, clock 02:44. |
| Wes | 4-6 | on Thi15 | Zach Baker field goal attempt from 32 GOOD, clock 02:40. |
| Thiel 16, Westminster 10 |
| | Drive: 7 plays, 60 yards, TOP 2:12 |
| | | J. Schnelbach kickoff 13 yards to the WES48, on-side kick, recovered by THI on WES48, PENALTY WES offside defense (Collin Wallace) 5 yards to the WES43, 1st and 10, THI ball on WES43. |
| Thi | 1-10 | on Wes43 | THIEL drive start at 02:40. |
| Thi | 1-10 | on Wes43 | Taylor Fink rush for loss of 2 yards to the WES45 (Christofferson). |
| Thi | 2-12 | on Wes45 | Timeout Westminster, clock 02:31. |
| Thi | 2-12 | on Wes45 | Taylor Fink rush for no gain to the WES45 (Josh Beistel). |
| Thi | 3-12 | on Wes45 | Timeout Westminster, clock 02:23. |
| Thi | 3-12 | on Wes45 | Taylor Fink rush for 3 yards to the WES42 (S. Kronenwetter). |
| Thi | 4-9 | on Wes42 | Cody McClelland punt 38 yards to the WES4, out-of-bounds. |
| | Drive: 3 plays, 1 yard, TOP 1:10 |
| Wes | 1-10 | on Wes04 | WESTMINSTER drive start at 01:30. |
| Wes | 1-10 | on Wes04 | Dak Britt pass incomplete to Collin Wallace. |
| Wes | 2-10 | on Wes04 | Dak Britt sacked for loss of 3 yards to the WES1 (Tim Taylor), fumble by Dak Britt recovered by WES Dan Graham at WES1. |
| Wes | 3-13 | on Wes01 | Dak Britt pass incomplete, QB hurry by Tim Taylor. |
| Wes | 4-13 | on Wes01 | Dak Britt pass incomplete to Collin Wallace (Rob Edwards). |
| | Drive: 4 plays, minus 3 yards, TOP 0:31 |
| Thi | 1-G | on Wes01 | THIEL drive start at 00:59. |
| Thi | 1-G | on Wes01 | Andrew Smith rush for loss of 1 yard to the WES2. |
| Thi | 2-G | on Wes02 | Andrew Smith rush for loss of 1 yard to the WES3. |
| Thi | 3-G | on Wes03 | End of game, clock 00:00. |
| | Drive: 2 plays, minus 2 yards, TOP 0:59 |
