Taking Sides: Herskovitz v. Pojman

 

 

Whose argument was more persuasive? Why?

 

Know both authors' stance & their arguments

     Herskovits’s claims & arguments?

    Pojman’s claims & arguments?

 

Spend time thinking about the arguments by both authors & see where you stand (write notes for class)?

 

Consider how you would defend your position (what points of the authors would you [dis]agree with?